The Sword of Kiri-Jolith

From RPGwiki

This mighty weapon is currently in the hands of the northern barbarians, who have as good a claim to owning it as anyone can have when it comes to such a powerful item. Many people believe that this sword was once wielded by Kiri-Jolith, the god of holy warfare - others claim that it is Kiri-Jolith!

In any event, it was broken into five separate pieces, many years ago. The heroes of the Vale reassembled it, and surprisingly, they actually gave it back to the barbarians afterwards.